Managed Services vs In-House IT
Compare outsourced managed services with building an internal IT team. Find the right approach based on your budget, needs, and growth plans.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Key factors to consider when choosing between managed services and in-house IT
| Factor | Managed Services | In-House IT | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront Costs | Low - monthly subscription | High - salaries, benefits, training | MSP |
| Predictable Expenses | Fixed monthly fee | Variable (turnover, training, tools) | MSP |
| Expertise Breadth | Wide - diverse team specializations | Limited - depends on team size | MSP |
| 24/7 Coverage | Included in most plans | Expensive - requires shifts/on-call | MSP |
| Scalability | Instant - adjust service level | Slow - hiring takes months | MSP |
| Institutional Knowledge | Documented, transferable | Deep but at-risk if staff leave | Depends |
| Response Time | SLA-guaranteed | Immediate for on-site issues | Depends |
| Cultural Fit | External partnership | Embedded in company culture | In-House |
| Control & Oversight | Contractual governance | Direct management | In-House |
| Physical Presence | Remote-first, on-site optional | On-site available | In-House |
True Cost Comparison
Understanding the full cost picture beyond just salaries vs. fees
In-House IT Team
4-person team example
Managed Services
100 users example
Potential Savings: $200K-500K/year
* Costs vary by region, complexity, and specific requirements. Contact us for a personalized assessment.
Three Approaches Explained
From fully outsourced to fully in-house, find the model that fits your organization
Fully Managed Services
Complete IT outsourcing
Outsource all IT operations to a managed service provider. Best for companies that want to focus entirely on core business.
Typical Cost Range
$5K-25K/month
Advantages
- Lowest total cost of ownership
- Access to diverse expertise
- 24/7 monitoring and support
- Predictable monthly expenses
- No recruitment or training burden
Challenges
- Less direct control
- Potential communication overhead
- Dependency on external provider
- May not understand business nuances initially
Ideal For
Best when: IT is not a core competency and you want predictable costs
Co-Managed IT
Hybrid partnership model
Combine internal IT staff with managed services for specialized functions. Best for extending capabilities without full outsourcing.
Typical Cost Range
$8K-40K/month + internal staff
Advantages
- Keeps institutional knowledge in-house
- Fills skill gaps without hiring
- Maintains direct control over strategy
- Flexible resource allocation
- Best of both worlds approach
Challenges
- Requires clear role definitions
- Potential for overlap or gaps
- More complex vendor management
- Higher cost than pure outsourcing
Ideal For
Best when: You have IT staff but need specialized expertise or coverage
Fully In-House IT
Complete internal team
Build and maintain a complete internal IT department. Best for organizations where IT is a strategic differentiator.
Typical Cost Range
$150K-500K+/year per FTE (fully loaded)
Advantages
- Complete control and oversight
- Deep institutional knowledge
- Immediate physical presence
- Cultural alignment
- Direct accountability
Challenges
- Highest total cost (salaries, benefits, training)
- Limited expertise breadth
- Recruitment challenges
- Single points of failure if staff leave
- Difficult to scale quickly
Ideal For
Best when: IT is a strategic differentiator and you have budget for a full team
Key Decision Factors
Consider these factors when deciding between managed services and in-house IT
Budget Constraints
Managed Services
Lower upfront costs, predictable monthly fees
In-House IT
Higher investment but potentially lower long-term costs at scale
Growth Plans
Managed Services
Scales instantly with your needs
In-House IT
Requires planning and hiring lead time
Security Requirements
Managed Services
Access to security specialists and 24/7 SOC
In-House IT
Direct control but expensive to build security team
Response Time Needs
Managed Services
SLA-guaranteed, often 15-minute response
In-House IT
Depends on staff availability and on-call setup
Company Size
Managed Services
Most cost-effective under 500 employees
In-House IT
Becomes viable at 200+ employees with complex needs
Technology Complexity
Managed Services
Broad expertise across technologies
In-House IT
Deep expertise in specific tech stack
Signs You Need a Change
Warning signs that your current IT approach may not be working
Signs You Need Managed Services
- IT staff is overwhelmed or burning out
- Security incidents are increasing
- Compliance audits are failing
- Technology decisions are reactive, not strategic
- Key IT person leaving would be catastrophic
- Struggling to attract or retain IT talent
- 24/7 coverage is needed but unaffordable
- Projects are constantly delayed due to support tickets
Signs You Might Need In-House IT
- MSP response times are too slow for your needs
- Unique technology requires deep specialization
- IT is a competitive differentiator
- Regulatory requirements mandate internal control
- Budget allows for full team with benefits
- Need constant on-site physical presence
- Communication with MSP is consistently problematic
- Business is large enough to justify full team
Not Sure? Consider Co-Managed IT
Many organizations find the hybrid approach offers the best of both worlds. Keep strategic control in-house while leveraging MSP expertise for specialized functions, 24/7 coverage, and scalable support.
Get a Free Security & Infrastructure Assessment
Understand your current security posture, identify critical risks, and get a prioritized roadmap for improvement.
What you'll receive
No commitment required. Assessment takes 48 hours. Report is yours to keep.
Assessment Preview
Areas we evaluate in your free assessment
Security Posture
A-F Rating
Infrastructure
Health Check
Access Controls
Gap Analysis
Vulnerabilities
Risk Score
Sample Report
See what you'll receive